Comparative market analysis

140 Catani Loop: what the market says

Georgetown, TX 78628 · Rancho Sienna Ph 2 Sec 14 · MLS 1003353 · Listed at $625,000

Living area
3,133 sq ft
Beds / baths
4 bd / 3 full + 1 half
Lot
0.24 acre
Built
2020
Garage
3-car
Stories
One story

Your home, front and back

Front of 140 Catani Loop at dusk
Entry hall at 140 Catani Loop Kitchen at 140 Catani Loop Flex room at 140 Catani Loop

What sold nearby in the last 90 days

Only sales that match your home on three points: in Rancho Sienna, closed in the last 90 days (August 22 to November 20, 2026), and within 500 sq ft of your 3,133 sq ft. Two sales qualify, and both are one-story. Net is the sale price minus what the seller paid toward the buyer's closing costs, from the MLS Sales Information section for each sale.

101 Pienza Dr

Closed October 28, 2026 · 46 days on market · 4 bd · 3 full + 1 half bath · 3,334 sq ft · built 2022 · 0.27 ac · 3-car garage

101 Pienza Dr front
101 Pienza Dr photo 2 101 Pienza Dr photo 3 101 Pienza Dr photo 4
Sold $699,900 − $0 seller-paid closing costs = $699,900 net ($210 per sq ft)

201 sq ft larger than yours, newer, and on a slightly bigger lot. It is the upper end of the market here, and no seller help went to the buyer.

205 Cortona Ln

Closed September 30, 2026 · 72 days on market · 4 bd · 3 full + 1 half bath · 2,786 sq ft · built 2015 · 0.18 ac · 3-car garage

205 Cortona Ln photo 1
205 Cortona Ln photo 2 205 Cortona Ln photo 3 205 Cortona Ln photo 4
Sold $491,400 − $0 seller-paid closing costs; buyer assumed the existing loan = $491,400 net ($176 per sq ft)

Same bedrooms, baths and garage as yours, 347 sq ft smaller, and 11 years older. It is the lower end of the market here.

Not used: 109 Serrano St and 145 Palio Pl sold in the same window, but both are two-story. Sales from older than 90 days, and homes outside the 500 sq ft range, are not used.


Side by side

HomeSq ftBd / baBuiltGarageSoldSeller paidNet$/sq ftDays
140 Catani (yours)3,1334 / 3.520203Listed $625,000———6
101 Pienza Dr3,3344 / 3.520223$699,900$0$699,900$21046
205 Cortona Ln2,7864 / 3.520153$491,400$0$491,400$17672

Seller-paid amounts are from the MLS Sales Information section (BCCST) for each sale. Pienza also lists $300 in repairs, which is not netted out here.


What the market says for your price

Applied to your 3,133 sq ft, the two sales point to two very different numbers. Pienza's $210 per sq ft gives about $658,000. Cortona's $176 per sq ft gives about $553,000. The average of the two is about $605,000.

Your home sits between them: newer than Cortona and a similar lot to Pienza, but smaller than Pienza. Two sales is a thin sample, so the average is a starting point, not a guarantee. Your $625,000 list price is above that average, so it would need a clear reason to hold, such as condition or upgrades.

Suggested list range
$595,000 to $615,000

Centered on the $605,000 average of the two sales. Pricing inside that range is most likely to sell in a reasonable time. Homes that started too high in this area sat for months and sold for less.


How many one-story homes you're competing with

1 active one-story home within 500 sq ft of yours: 169 Catani Loop, 2,936 sq ft, listed at $645,000. It's the one to watch, because it's in your price range.

8 more one-story homes are active in Rancho Sienna, but outside the size range:

Between $400,000 and $475,000: 232 Prato Pl ($474,000, 2,386 sq ft), 240 Prato Pl ($439,000, 2,388 sq ft), 440 Saturnia Dr ($429,000, 2,286 sq ft), 60 Rancho Trl ($420,000, 1,961 sq ft), and 101 San Miniato St ($410,000, 2,135 sq ft).

Under $400,000: 212 La Grotta Ln ($370,000, 2,006 sq ft), 218 Bonnet Blvd ($331,990, 1,430 sq ft), and 700 Affazia Ln Unit C ($315,000, 1,456 sq ft).

Counted from the MLS: active, single-family, one-story only, in Rancho Sienna. Two 1.5-story homes (211 Prato Pl and 152 Florenz Ln) are not counted.

More homes at your price means more competition, which usually means a lower final price and more time on the market.


What you'd walk away with

An estimate at a $610,000 sale price, from the Independence Title seller net sheet.

Sale price$610,000.00
Loan payoff− $490,000.00
Listing fee (flat)− $2,000.00
Buyer's agent commission (3%)− $18,300.00
Prorated 2026 taxes (estimate)− $15,157.22
Other closing costs (title, escrow, lender, fees)− $5,169.95
Estimated net to you$79,372.83